Question 1

What is RNOR status and how does it help returning NRIs?

Accepted Answer

Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident (RNOR) is a tax status under Section 6(6) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. When you return to India after being an NRI for several years, you do not immediately become a fully Resident taxpayer. During RNOR, your foreign income (US salary, 401(k) withdrawals, US rental income, US investment gains, interest from foreign bank accounts) is NOT taxable in India. Only Indian-source income and income received in India is taxed. This gives you a 2-3 year window to optimize withdrawals and asset sales before India starts taxing your worldwide income.

Question 2

How long does RNOR status last?

Accepted Answer

RNOR is assessed year by year based on two tests under Section 6(6): (1) Were you a non-resident in 9 out of the 10 preceding years? (2) Was your total stay in India 729 days or less in the preceding 7 years? You are RNOR for any year you meet either test. In practice, NRIs who have been abroad 9-15 years typically get 2 years of RNOR status. Those abroad 15+ years may get 3 years because the 9-out-of-10 test continues to pass even after 1-2 years of residency. The exact duration depends on your specific travel history.

Question 3

What income is tax-free in India during RNOR status?

Accepted Answer

During RNOR, the following foreign income is not taxable in India: income earned outside India (US employment income earned before you moved), capital gains from selling US assets (stocks, property, mutual funds), interest from US bank accounts, 401(k) and IRA distributions, US rental income, and dividends from US companies. Indian-source income (salary from an Indian employer, rental income from Indian property, interest from Indian bank accounts other than NRE) remains taxable in India during RNOR. The key distinction is whether the income is earned or accrued outside India.

Question 4

What happens to my NRE account when I return to India?

Accepted Answer

Your NRE (Non-Resident External) savings account must be redesignated as a regular resident savings account or converted to an RFC (Resident Foreign Currency) account after your status changes from NRI to Resident. You should inform your bank within a reasonable time. NRE fixed deposits, however, can continue until maturity at the same interest rate, and the interest remains tax-free until maturity (per CBDT Circular 11/2002). This is a major benefit. Lock in long-term NRE FDs at the best rates before returning. After maturity, the renewed deposit will be treated as a regular resident FD with taxable interest.

Question 5

Should I keep my US bank account after returning to India?

Accepted Answer

Yes, keep at least one US bank account and one credit card. You will need them for: receiving any pending US income (tax refunds, final paychecks, investment distributions), maintaining your US credit history, paying ongoing US obligations (student loans, subscriptions, insurance), and managing US investments if your broker allows non-resident accounts. Check if your bank charges inactivity fees and set up a small recurring transaction to keep the account active. Note: as an Indian Resident, you must report foreign bank accounts under Schedule FA (Foreign Assets) of your India tax return if the aggregate balance exceeds Rs 5,00,000.

Question 6

What happens to my 401(k) when I move back to India?

Accepted Answer

Your US 401(k) and IRA accounts stay in the US. You cannot transfer them to an Indian retirement account like NPS (National Pension System). You have several options: (1) Leave the money invested and withdraw later. (2) Roll over to an IRA for more investment flexibility. (3) Take strategic withdrawals during your RNOR period, when distributions are taxable only in the US, not in India. After RNOR, 401(k) withdrawals are taxable in both countries under DTAA Article 20, though you can claim a Foreign Tax Credit. The early withdrawal penalty (10% before age 59.5) still applies regardless of where you live. Consider Roth conversions while still in the US to pay US tax at known rates.

Question 7

Do I still need to file US taxes after returning to India?

Accepted Answer

It depends on your immigration status. If you held a green card and formally abandoned it (Form I-407), you file a dual-status return for the departure year, then switch to Form 1040-NR for subsequent years only if you have US-source income (rental income, US investment gains, 401(k) withdrawals). If you were on a work visa (H-1B, L-1), your US filing obligation generally ends when you leave, except for US-source income. If you are a US citizen, you must file US returns regardless of where you live (worldwide income). Also check if you trigger the expatriation tax under IRC Section 877A if you held a green card for 8+ years. FBAR filing continues as long as you have foreign accounts exceeding $10,000 (which includes US accounts once you are an Indian resident).

Question 8

What about US Social Security benefits if I return to India?

Accepted Answer

The US-India Social Security Totalization Agreement (effective 2015) allows you to combine work credits from both countries to qualify for benefits. If you worked in the US long enough to earn 40 credits (roughly 10 years), you are eligible for US Social Security benefits regardless of where you live. Benefits are paid to Indian bank accounts via international wire. Under the India-US DTAA (Article 20), Social Security payments are taxable only in the country of residence, so they would be taxable in India after RNOR ends. During RNOR, they are foreign income and not taxable in India. The US may still withhold 25.5% on payments to non-residents, but you can file Form 1040-NR to claim a refund or reduction.

Question 9

What happens to my US investments (stocks, ETFs, mutual funds)?

Accepted Answer

US brokerage accounts can generally remain open, but many brokers (Vanguard, some Fidelity accounts) restrict trading for non-US residents. Check your broker's policy before moving. Schwab International and Interactive Brokers typically continue serving clients who move abroad. For tax purposes: gains realized during RNOR are not taxable in India (foreign income). After RNOR, gains are taxable in both countries with Foreign Tax Credit relief. Consider harvesting capital gains during the RNOR window. US dividends will have 25% withholding under the DTAA (Article 10), but you can claim this as a credit on your India return. You must also report US investments under Schedule FA of your India tax return once you become a Resident.

Question 10

When should I start planning my return to India?

Accepted Answer

Start at least 12 months before your planned move date. Here is the timeline: 12 months out: consult a US CPA and Indian CA to map your tax strategy, begin Roth conversions if applicable, review 401(k) withdrawal strategy. 6 months out: update KYC on Indian bank accounts, lock in NRE FDs at best rates, consolidate US investment accounts, check broker policies on non-resident accounts. 3 months out: close unnecessary US accounts, file or extend US tax return, inform Indian banks of upcoming status change. On arrival: update bank status from NRI to Resident, apply for Aadhaar if needed, set up Indian brokerage account. The most expensive mistake is last-minute planning. NRIs who do not plan lose the RNOR window and miss thousands of dollars in tax optimization.

Return to India Tax Planner: Frequently Asked Questions